Want to discuss these deals? Apply to join the members-only MilesTalk Facebook group.
Advertising Disclosure: Links and credit card offers on this page may earn us a small commission. They never influence what we cover but they do keep the lights on. Learn More

NOTE: On January 12th, 2020, the Chase Sapphire Reserve‘s annual fee went from $450 to $550 and added new benefits with DoorDash and Lyft. This post compares the two cards taking into account the new benefits.

The new Lyft benefits are:

If you are in a cash crunch, you should avoid travel rewards credit cards until you are caught up. Here are our favorite credit cards for Intro 0% APR offers and for balance transfer offers

The new DoorDash credits are only for the Chase Sapphire Reserve:

  • Get $60 in DoorDash credits each year in 2020 and 2021.

Both cards offer a free one-time DoorDash “DashPass” subscription. 

  • Get free DashPass to get free DoorDash deliveries at select restaurants with $12 or more in your order and decreased service charges. Valid from now through the end of Dec 2021 or for a minimum of one year when activated any time before then.

One of the most common questions I’m asked is which Sapphire card somebody should start with: the Chase Sapphire Reserve or the Chase Sapphire Preferred.

Let’s take a quick step back. There are four primary cards that Chase offers that earn Ultimate Rewards points on the consumer side:

We’ll save the Freedoms for another post.

YourBestCreditCards

First, let’s break down the highlights of each card:

 Chase Sapphire ReserveChase Sapphire Preferred
Signup Bonus50,000 Ultimate Rewards points with $4,000 in spend within 3 months60,000 Ultimate Rewards points with $4,000 in spend within 3 months
Annual Fee$550$95
NET EFFECTIVE Annual Fee$250 if you use the full annual $300 travel credit.$95
Redemption value in Ultimate Rewards portal?Yes, at 1.5 cents per point
(50,000 points equals $750 in travel)
Yes, at 1.25 cents per point (50,000 points equals $625 in travel)
DoorDash BenefitsFree "DashPass" membership (free delivery on select restaurants when you spend $12 or more) from now through the end of Dec 2021 or for a minimum of one year when activated any time before then.Free "DashPass" membership (free delivery on select restaurants when you spend $12 or more) from now through the end of Dec 2021 or for a minimum of one year when activated any time before then.
Door Dash Credits$60 in 2020
$60 in 2021
None
Lyft Earning RateEarns 10X Chase Ultimate Rewards points on Lyft ridesEarns 5X Chase Ultimate Rewards points on Lyft rides
Lyft BenefitsGet a one-time complimentary Lyft Pink subscription (15% Lyft discounts, free bike/scooter rentals each month, and better cancellation rules). This is a $240 value.None
Transfers to airline and hotel partners?YesYes
Airport Lounge AccessYes, via Priority Pass. For you and up to two guests. Unlimited visits.No
Global Entry or PreCheck reimbursement?Yes, up to $100 once every 5 years.No
Trip Delay CoverageYes, up to $500 after a 6 hour delay. Must have used card to purchase at least part of trip. Paying with Ultimate Rewards points counts.Yes, up to $500 after a 12 hour delay. Must have used card to purchase at least part of trip. Paying with Ultimate Rewards points counts.
Car Rental Damage Waiver Insurance?Yes, PrimaryYes, Primary
Roadside assistanceYes, covering up to $50 in roadside assistance (i.e. towing, help with a flat, etc) up to 4 times a yearYes, but only the call is covered. Any assistance provided such as a towing is at your own expense.
Trip Cancellation / Interruption CoverageYes (excludes travel provider insolvency)Yes (excludes travel provider insolvency)
Lost / Delayed Luggage Coverage?Yes, up to $3,000. Other limits apply.Yes, up to $3,000. Other limits apply.

It’s very important to note that you can combine your rewards from any Ultimate Rewards earning card. So if you have a Reserve, which allows redemptions in the UR portal at 1.5 cents per point, you can combine points earned on a Chase Freedom Unlimited or Chase Freedom into your Chase Sapphire Reserve account. Many people carry multiple cards for this reason. You simply put whatever purchase you are making on the card that will earn the most points and combine later.  Even with the Chase Sapphire Preferred, you could transfer in points from a no-fee Freedom card in order to utilize transfer partners.

Now, let’s get back to the topic at hand.

You want the ability to transfer to Chase’s nice list of transfer partners such as United or Hyatt, so that rules out the Freedom cards as cards to start with.

Do you choose the Chase Sapphire Reserve or the Chase Sapphire Preferred?

The answer to that is, of course, based on your own needs.

My goal is to give you the most efficient comparison so that you can make an informed decision.

First, the bonus offers:

The bonus offers on the two cards are similar, but the $95 annual fee Chase Sapphire Preferred actually has a bonus offer that nets you 10,000 more Chase Ultimate Rewards points than the Chase Sapphire Reserve.

Chase Sapphire Reserve Bonus Offer:

50,000 Ultimate Rewards points when you spend $4,000 in 3 months

Chase Sapphire Preferred Bonus Offer:

60,000 Ultimate Rewards points when you spend $4,000 in 3 months

The Chase Sapphire Preferred clearly has a better bonus, with an extra 10,000 Chase Ultimate Rewards points for the same minimum spend.

Next, the annual fees:

The Chase Sapphire Reserve has a “sticker” annual fee of $550, while the Chase Sapphire Preferred has a $95 annual fee.

If you spend $300 a year on travel – which Chase loosely defines as all airline, hotel, parking, Uber/Lyft, and taxi purchases – then your $550 annual fee on the Reserve is reduced down to $250. This is because these travel credits are automatic. Spend them within a cardmember year and you will see them instantly refunded to you until the credit is used up. I personally use mine up within a month each year.

To make that even simpler: If you spend $300 in travel purchases per year, your net effective annual fee is $250 on the Chase Sapphire Reserve vs $95 on a Chase Sapphire Preferred. This is a $155 difference.

Decision tree: If you DO NOT spend $300 a year on Travel, you most likely should get the Chase Sapphire Preferred for now.  If you do, continue….

I can’t stress enough that if you want a Sapphire card (because you want to be able to transfer points to airline or hotel partners), you need one or the other. So once we know you are getting either a Chase Sapphire Reserve or Chase Sapphire Preferred card, the decision comes down to the $155 difference in annual fee.

Looking back at the chart above, let’s breakout what you get for that $155 a year:

  • 3x points on Travel and Dining (vs. 2x with Preferred)
  • 10X on Lyft rides vs. 5X on the Preferred (worth a lot if you use Lyft a lot, else not worth much at all)
  • Free one year of Lyft Pink (worth $240, but only if you use Lyft regularly)
  • $60 in DoorDash credits in 2020 and $60 in 2021
  • Redemption of your points in the Ultimate Rewards portal for 1.5 cents per point (vs. 1.25)
  • Priority Pass Lounge access for you and two guests
  • $100 Global Entry/PreCheck credit every 5 years
  • Trip Delay coverage at 6 hours (vs. 12 hours)

How do we calculate if you’ll get the extra $155 in value?

There are many ways in which you come out ahead by paying the extra $155 fee. And it’s a sum total of all of the above that determines it. Let’s say you spend $200 a month in travel and dining. That extra $2,400 a year will earn you 2,400 extra points on the Reserve – worth $36. (Although, to be technical, you don’t earn points on the first $300 in travel you get a credit for – so it’s really 1,500 points worth $26.25 in this case).

Let’s say you redeem points through the portal for a plane ticket that costs $400. That will cost 26,666 points with Reserve or 32,000 points with the Chase Sapphire Preferred. At a bare minimum per point value of 1.25, those 5,334 saved points are worth $66.

Visits to a lounge without a free Priority Pass membership can cost $25-$50 a visit per person. Several lounge visits in a year would cover that $155 – if you care about airline lounges.

The DoorDash benefit of $60 in credit per year can come right off that $155 - if you have DoorDash where you live and would use it anyway.

And the Lyft Pink benefit, which most notably gets you 15% off for a year + the extra 5X points per dollar on Lyft rides can really add up – but again, if you live where Lyft is prevalent and use it often.

For perspective, in Manhattan it’s not a stretch to say that many spend $500 a month on taxis/rideshares. That’s $6,000 a year (remember, this is instead of owning a car for most, so it’s less crazy than it sounds). You’d save $900 with the Lyft Pink discount (but only for one year) plus earn that extra 5X points per dollar. On that $5,100 a year after the 15% off, you’d net an extra 25,500 Ultimate Rewards points worth $446.25 based on my miles and points valuations chart.

As you can see, if you travel even a reasonable amount, the Chase Sapphire Reserve quickly becomes the better value, despite a higher “sticker price” on the annual fee.

However, if you will not use the travel credit, nor the benefits I discuss above, then the Chase Sapphire Preferred should suit you just fine.

I think the best way to see if you should go for the Chase Sapphire Reserve or Chase Sapphire Preferred is to fill in this table with your own valuations of the new benefits. i.e. do you get $100 in benefits out of the extra $100 in annual fee?

Worksheet:

Chase Sapphire Reserve vs. Chase Sapphire Preferred Benefits- Your Personal Value

 Chase Sapphire Preferred (Review)List the value of each Chase Sapphire Reserve benefit for you.Chase Sapphire Preferred (Review)List the value of each Chase Sapphire Preferred benefit for you.
Signup Bonus50,000 Ultimate Rewards points with $4,000 in spend within 3 months__________________80,000 Ultimate Rewards points with $4,000 in spend within 3 months__________________
Annual Fee$550n/a$95n/a
NET EFFECTIVE Annual Fee$250 if you use the full annual $300 travel credit.n/a$95n/a
Redemption value in Ultimate Rewards portal?Yes, at 1.5 cents per point
(50,000 points equals $750 in travel)
__________________Yes, at 1.25 cents per point (50,000 points equals $625 in travel)__________________
DoorDash BenefitsFree "DashPass" membership (free delivery on select restaurants when you spend $12 or more) from now through the end of Dec 2021 or for a minimum of one year when activated any time before then.__________________Free "DashPass" membership (free delivery on select restaurants when you spend $12 or more) from now through the end of Dec 2021 or for a minimum of one year when activated any time before then.__________________
Door Dash Credits$60 in 2020
$60 in 2021
__________________None__________________
Lyft Earning RateEarns 10X Chase Ultimate Rewards points on Lyft rides__________________Earns 5X Chase Ultimate Rewards points on Lyft rides__________________
Lyft BenefitsGet a one-time complimentary Lyft Pink subscription (15% Lyft discounts, free bike/scooter rentals each month, and better cancellation rules). This is a $240 value.__________________None__________________
Transfers to airline and hotel partners?Yes__________________Yes__________________
Airport Lounge AccessYes, via Priority Pass. For you and up to two guests. Unlimited visits.__________________No__________________
Global Entry or PreCheck reimbursement?Yes, up to $100 once every 5 years.__________________No__________________
Trip Delay CoverageYes, up to $500 after a 6 hour delay. Must have used card to purchase at least part of trip. Paying with Ultimate Rewards points counts.__________________Yes, up to $500 after a 12 hour delay. Must have used card to purchase at least part of trip. Paying with Ultimate Rewards points counts.__________________
Car Rental Damage Waiver Insurance?Yes, Primary__________________Yes, Primary__________________
Trip Cancellation / Interruption CoverageYes (excludes travel provider insolvency)__________________Yes (excludes travel provider insolvency)__________________
Lost / Delayed Luggage Coverage?Yes, up to $3,000. Other limits apply.__________________Yes, up to $3,000. Other limits apply.__________________
Total Chase Sapphire Reserve Value to You__________________Total Chase Sapphire Preferred Value to You__________________

As an aside, if you don’t even plan to utilize the airline and hotel transfer partners, your best bet may actually be a card that earns 2% cash back, though if you are willing to put in just a little effort you should be able to get better value with a Chase Sapphire Reserve or Chase Sapphire Preferred.

Want to take a look at current signup bonuses or compare various card benefits? Your best resource is YourBestCreditCards.com, by MilesTalk, which helps you find the best card for you based on your own spending habits.


Have any questions or comments? Let me know here, on Twitter, or in the private MilesTalk Facebook group.

New to all of this? My new “introduction to miles and points” book, MilesTalk: Live Your Wildest Travel Dreams Using Miles and Points is available now.

yottaWhat is Yotta Savings?: The Yotta Savigs account is a really fun way to earn interest at a higher rate than Marcus while having some fun each night when the Yotta prize ball drops. Currently, the statistical odds imply a net savings rate of between around 1% and 3% - at a time when banks like Marcus are offering a paltry 0.5%. Plus, it's fun! | Read my review of Yotta.


I got "in the game" in 2003 and since then I've collected literally millions and millions of frequent flyer miles and hotel points. I've flown around the world in first class seats that would cost $29,000 using frequent flyer miles and a few bucks in tax. And I've stayed in some of the finest hotels - all for free! A few years ago I realized many of my friends actually thought I was paying for these!! So I started sharing my tips. It's long been a passion, but when I hosted a session on Miles and Points at this year's South by Southwest festival, my love of the game intensified and this blog was born.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here