Want to discuss these deals? Apply to join the members-only MilesTalk Facebook group.
Advertising Disclosure: Links and credit card offers on this page may earn us a small commission. They never influence what we cover but they do keep the lights on. Learn More

Looking to apply for a new Citi Premier, Citi Prestige, or Rewards+ card?

Citi’s 1/24 Rule on ThankYou cards

Citi has more confusing rules than any other issuer, including Chase and its 5/24 rule. They are certainly the only issuer that has language around when you closed a card (that isn’t even the one you are applying for) and uses that to make you ineligible for a new card bonus on another card.

If you are in a cash crunch, you should avoid travel rewards credit cards until you are caught up. Here are our favorite credit cards for Intro 0% APR offers and for balance transfer offers

If you look at the application page for any of Citi’s ThankYou earning cards, you’ll find this language:

Bonus ThankYouĀ® Points are not available if you received a new cardmember bonus for Citi Rewards+ā„ , Citi ThankYouĀ® Preferred, Citi ThankYouĀ®Premier/Citi Premierā„  or Citi PrestigeĀ®, or if you have closed any of these accounts, in the past 24 months.

So if you are looking at ANY of the above cards and have or recently had any of the above cards, you’ll really need to think about how to play it.

Let’s say you opened a Rewards+ card 20 months ago and now think a Premier card, with a 60,000 point bonus, sounds enticing. You’ll need to wait 4 months.

But let’s say you only have a Citi Prestige card you opened 6 years ago. You want to cancel it now and get a Premier card. Well, youĀ can apply for the Premier, get the bonus, and then close the Prestige. But you cannot close the Prestige and then get the Premier.

YourBestCreditCards

Needless to say, if you have a no-fee card like the Preferred or Rewards+, just leave it alone forever. It’s when you are figuring out what to do with the fee-based cards that things get dicey.

(If you are REALLY going to close your card and not downgrade, by the way, read about Citi Premier/Prestige retention offers.)

What happens if you downgrade a Premier or Prestige?

For the more experienced players out there, this is your next question.

The answer is that it won’t count as an account closure so long as your card number doesn’t change. Downgrading either a Premier or Prestige to a Rewards+ or Preferred card should not trigger a new card number. If you last got a bonus 24 or more months ago and want to get a new bonus, just make sure you downgrade and don’t close your account. This will also preserve your points (though you can’t transfer to airlines without a Premier or Prestige card anyway).

What about Citi AAdvantage credit cards?

These now follow a different Citi AAdvantage 1/48 rule, which limits you to one bonus per 48 months on the exact same card.

You can get the bonus on all four cards (theĀ Citi / AAdvantage Platinum Select World Elite Mastercard, CitiBusinessĀ® / AAdvantageĀ® Platinum SelectĀ® MastercardĀ®,Ā theĀ Citi / AAdvantage Executive World Elite Mastercard,Ā and theĀ American Airlines AAdvantage MileUp CardĀ once every 48 months.

Bottom Line

Citi likes to keep us on our toes. As long as you downgrade correctly, you should still be able to get a bonus every 24 months, but you must pay close attention. You’ll also only be able to get one ThankYou bonusĀ total in that timeframe, so choose wisely.

Generally the Premier and Prestige have the best bonus offers, though both have annual fees and neither are waived the first year. The Rewards+, by contrast, generally has a much smaller bonus (but no annual fee). When you do the math, you will always want a Premier or Prestige bonus unless your specific circumstances dictate otherwise. You are allowed to have multiple cards and this restriction notably does not include “if you have the card you are applying for.”

So yes, you can still downgrade a Premier and then get a new one as long as you meet the restriction about 24 months since your last bonus.

Questions?

Let me know below in the comments, on Twitter, or in theĀ privateĀ MilesTalk Facebook group.

And if this post helped you, please consider sharing it!

You can find credit cards that best match your spending habits and bonus categories at Your Best Credit Cards.Ā 

New to all of this? My ā€œintroduction to miles and pointsā€ book, MilesTalk: Live Your Wildest Travel Dreams Using Miles and Points is available on Amazon and at major booksellers.


I got "in the game" in 2003 and since then I've collected literally millions and millions of frequent flyer miles and hotel points. I've flown around the world in first class seats that would cost $29,000 using frequent flyer miles and a few bucks in tax. And I've stayed in some of the finest hotels - all for free! A few years ago I realized many of my friends actually thought I was paying for these!! So I started sharing my tips. It's long been a passion, but when I hosted a session on Miles and Points at this year's South by Southwest festival, my love of the game intensified and this blog was born.

6 COMMENTS

  1. If my Premier was closed on Dec 10, 2018, would I be eligble for the Premier bonus again on Dec 11, 2020 or would I need to wait until Jan 1, 2021?

    • Hi Rajadat: It would be the later of 24 months from closing the card and/or receiving the bonus. So, Dec 11th (maybe wait a few more days to be safe) would be fine assuming you didn’t receive the bonus after that date somehow.

  2. Great pointers Dave! Just what I’ve been thinking just these last couple of days. Have the Premier–24 months coming up (annual fee in a couple weeks & bonus rcv’d in a couple months) and don’t want to pay another $95 AF so was thinking of how to move/retain the points. Thought of downgrading the Premier to Rewards + and then signing up for it again early next year. However, do you know what the data points are about retaining the same card number when we downgrade (eg. can we specifically request Citi if we can have the same #)? Thanks!

    • That’s a great question. While the Citi rep should be able to advise you in theory, they also may get it wrong. Of course, you DO always have the option to reverse a Citi conversion for something like 45 days, so that’s a great feature at Citi.

      I’m 99.9% sure the Premier/Prestige > Preferred keep the number. I THINK the same for Rewards+ but am not sure positive. Hopefully some others can drop some datapoints here in the comments šŸ™‚

  3. Great article Dave. The datapoints on my usual places are fewer than I would like on downgrading a prestige or premier in the prior 24 months. It does seem reasonably clear that with no number change that it will work but I canā€™t find too many first hand reports that it has actually worked. I also saw one datapoint of someone who said they got a sign up bonus on premier even with a number change from prestige. I am limiting application to get ready to be under 5/24 and am a little worried about risking it.

    • Yes, I’ve heard anecdotal reports of it being OK even with a card number change, but not enough to think that is standard. Also, the rules have bounced around over the years and there was a period of time where there was no “open or closed” language which greatly simplified things. That didn’t last šŸ˜‰

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here